Enameled cast iron???

topic posted Mon, March 31, 2008 - 12:32 PM by 
I searched the past posts and did not find the info I was looking for so here it goes...

We were given a le creuset enameled stoneware baking dish that I love, love, love! (Did not think I would, but I do. Ask me why and I'll wax on about it at great length...)

That got me wondering... Does anyone know about/ is familiar with/ have opinions on their enameled cast iron? Is it worth the expense? (We were getting ready to invest in a couple of long term pieces, but since the stoneware piece, have been thinking about the the le creuset.)

Does the enameled coating really make a difference? Or is it just pretty? (On their website, they mention that you can use the enameled cast iron baking dish as a skillet on the stove top... Any experience with this? Sticking? Flavor?)

What do you think?
posted by:
  • Re: Enameled cast iron???

    Mon, March 31, 2008 - 3:55 PM
    LOVE IT!!! I have a couple of pieces (8 qt. saucier and 4 qt. saucier) that rock my socks off. My parents had Le Cruset in the 70s in tomato, updated a piece or 2 in the 80s to almond. Mine are blue, though I like the citrus colored ones, too.

    Seriously, though, they are super worth it. Even heating, non stick but not teflon-y gross, very quick clean up.
    • Re: Enameled cast iron???

      Mon, March 31, 2008 - 3:57 PM
      Oh! Depending on where you live, there may be a Le Cruset outlet store near you, too. As for expense, I'd say don't shell our for a set, but get them one at a time.

      xoM
  • Mo
    Mo
    offline 59

    Re: Enameled cast iron???

    Mon, March 31, 2008 - 6:42 PM
    I have a few pieces. I love them. The advantage of the enamel is that they have a lower-stick (not quite non-stick but close) surface, and more than that, they are easier to clean than regular old cast iron. They're specialized though - like any cast iron pan, they're too heavy for cooking things you'll want to shake or flip. They can go from the stove top to the oven (or vice versa), which I love. I have two dutch ovens that I use for roasting chicken, pot roast, stews, etc. The lids seal really tight to keep everything warm and steamy inside. And I have a grill pan for winter grilling. But I definitely don't use them for everything, I think you need to have a variety different kinds of pans for doing different jobs. BTW, the smaller dutch ovens (2-3 qt.) are not too expensive and really handy.
    • Re: Enameled cast iron???

      Mon, March 31, 2008 - 10:25 PM
      Awesome! I had forgotten about the aspect of starting a dish on the stove top and then completing it in the oven.

      They have a couple of pieces at Macy's that we thought we would go take a look at just to see them in person, and then order the ones we really want online.

      Do you know if the lids of the cast iron pieces can go on the stoneware without damaging them?
  • Re: Enameled cast iron???

    Wed, April 2, 2008 - 8:20 AM
    I like the stuff, but it is heavy. Some of the older stuff is actually lighter I think. I like the fact that there is no metal in contact with your food, but there are lot's of times I like stainless better. I use the enameled stuff for longer stewing and baking things mostly. I like my really large frying pan shaped one with a domed lid for cooking things that simmer for a long time. I like the little dutch oven ones for baking things in, and I wish I had a baking dish type one, a pretty big soup pot and a bigger dutch oven. I can't tell you how many of those dutch oven types I've passed up because they were that ugly orange. At this point I would just buy one anyway. I don't like the sauce pans much because of the weight, and prefer my light stainless saute pan for most wet saute type stuff. I did have a light weight enameled saute pan that I loved, but someone dropped it and it broke:( All of mine are thrift store finds and some of them are pretty nice. Don't get caught up on new stuff and brand names too much. One last thing. I don't think that these at all replace cast iron. I use cast Iron for dry frying and oily stuff only, like Crepes, pancakes, scrambled eggs, hashbrowns etc... anything too wet ruins the seasoning and picks up iron from the pan. That's what cast iron is good for.
  • Re: Enameled cast iron???

    Wed, April 2, 2008 - 9:48 AM
    These are my favorite pieces of cookware for a wide variety of reasons - the fact that they're relatively non-stick being one but the main one being the way heat is distributed and they hold the heat. I inherited some from my mother that were bought in the 70s (though a roommate did destroy one, which was quite tragic, so tragic that I still remember it though it happened years ago! ;). Considering that they last a lifetime (or two or more) if properly taken care of, they're well worth the investment. You don't necessarily have to buy le creuset, there are a lot of other people making enameled cast iron cookware these days too (and not all the pieces I've picked up over the years are le creuset, there are a lot of other European brands of enameled cookware). Also, it's possible to have them re-enameled if the enamel gets destroyed somehow.
  • Re: Enameled cast iron???

    Wed, April 2, 2008 - 9:01 PM
    Hi Aislinn,

    I love my enameled cast iron by Le Creuset. My collection includes a dutch oven, a fondue set, and a small skillet. For everything else I use a 10" lodge cast iron skillet and all-clad stainless steel cookware.

    I won't rehash what everyone else said, but I strongly recommend you haunt the Le Creuset outlet stores as you can get some killer deals if you're willing to limit yourself on colors. Each of my pieces was acquired for half the retail price because i was willing to wait for sales or accept a very minor flaw in the paint job. I recommend you pick up a piece at a time rather than buying a set. I don't know where in California you live, but I had good experiences at the Gilroy store back in the day.
    • Re: Enameled cast iron???

      Thu, April 10, 2008 - 7:43 AM
      I am so there! I live in the South Bay so that is exactly where I had thought to go (after the initial Macy's test to see if I liked them, since they are down the street...) I think I'll head right there and skip the other stores... And by the piece suits me just fine... If they are anything as fantastic as the bake ware piece that I love so much, and half as wonderful as you all have said, I may never use anything else again... (Thank you!)
      • Re: Enameled cast iron???

        Sat, April 12, 2008 - 10:38 AM
        I love love love mine too. I have a few other stainless steel pieces and I even like to keep a couple of cheap nonstick skillets around, but for *most* intents and purposes I have a full set of enameled cast iron that are my main cookware. I think my favorite is my large oval baking dish which makes miracles with roasted potatoes.

        Love love love my enameled cast iron and I'll cook with them until I'm an old lady and can't lift 'em anymore,
    • Re: Enameled cast iron???

      Sun, April 13, 2008 - 11:11 AM
      Estate sales and TJ Maxx are also good places to find them. TJ Maxx usually carries non-Creuset enameled cast iron pots, but they do get the branded ones from time to time. I picked up my 5 1/2 quart La Creuset dutch oven at an estate sale for $30. It was in great condition.
  • Re: Enameled cast iron???

    Thu, April 17, 2008 - 5:44 AM
    The reason to enamel cast iron is to prevent certain unpleasant chemical reactions form occuring during cooking, specifically acidic foods will pick up unpleasant colors and flavors from the iron. Cast Iron is a really durable and conductive metal for cookware, and is superior to most other metals, so I guess originally enamelling was an attempt to enable cooks to have the benefits of irons positive qualities while also being able to use acidic ingredients. The biggest problem with enamelled cast iron is its tendency to chip, especially with hard use, after which it's almost impossible to repair.
    If you value your enamelware, I suggest treating it gently, using wooden spoons and spatulas, cleaning with non abrasives and such.
    Personally, I don't own any of it, and probably wouldn't buy it for this very reason. I've always found that a heavy stainless steel pan works best overall. Good luck!
    • Re: Enameled cast iron???

      Wed, May 14, 2008 - 11:19 AM
      I did not think that I was being hard on my pan and pots, but maybe I was because all of mine got chipped over the years and looked terrible. And the chips affected the cooking as well. They are so pretty, I always am tempted to buy some more, but I did not like them that much to be honest. Just my two cents~
      • Re: Enameled cast iron???

        Wed, May 14, 2008 - 12:01 PM
        I was given one of these teapots, baby pink.. freakin love it!! If it werent for the mass amount of pots and pans i already have i would totally buy more of the set :)

Recent topics in "Food Geeks"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
question about prepared garlic Palff 15 June 29, 2008
pea shoots Mo 1 June 16, 2008
bacteria and the iron skillet <-·´¯`·.(¯`•... 6 May 14, 2008
Meyer Lemons 14 May 8, 2008
Soy it isn't so. 11 May 6, 2008